Racism and the Swing
Era
As jazz music gained popularity, it
moved from being a music “for blacks” to a music played by blacks, who catered
to a mostly white audience. There was also a spike in the number of white
musicians playing jazz music, which played for a predominantly white audience,
creating racial tension in the process. This shift of audience created a new
dialogue between the jazz musicians and white audience, from which we can see
the emergence of the “Swing Era” of the 1930s. The Swing Era represents a clash
between races, brought about by the rising number of white musicians and agents
who controlled black musicians through their greater access to resources such
as nightclub bookings and recording opportunities.
Duke Ellington was one black jazz
musician who recognized this racial tension between white and black musicians
and audiences, and was able to accept the contradictions of jazz and use them
to his advantage. A lot of his success can be attributed to his strategic
hiring of Irving Mills, a white agent who raised Duke’s profile, got him radio
appearances and national tour dates that allowed Duke to survive as a black
jazz musician. In return, however, Irving Mills got co-authorship of
Ellington’s composition, which put Duke at a financial disadvantage.
Regardless, Ellington was able to find success as a black jazz musician because
of his partnership with Irving Mills, who connected him with the growing white
audience during the Swing Era.
In contrast to Duke Ellington, many
other black jazz musicians suffered from this racial tension that arose during
the Swing Era, especially Fletcher Henderson. Fletcher Henderson, unlike Duke
Ellington, did not learn to accept the racial tension and instead tried to find
success as a jazz musician on his own, without the help of a white agent like
Irving Mills. Duke, unlike Fletcher, therefore booked many more performances in
major nightclubs like The Cotton Club in Harlem, in which he played for a
solely white audience. Duke even began to receive criticism from radical
whites, like John Hammond, who called him out for not speaking out about the
racism occurring around him. Referring to Duke’s Black, Brown, and Beige composition, Gioia explains that “With
encouragement, Ellington might have pushed further in the directions outlined
by this massive composition. Instead the mixed reactions of the critics gave
him pause”(177). This statement acknowledges the fact that Ellington’s
compositions were largely played in order to please his audience, which became
predominantly white during the 1930s.
The Swing Era represented a time of
conflict between the races, which was exacerbated by the competition between
black jazz musicians and the rising number of white jazz musicians in the
1930s. Radicals like John Hammond brought light to these racial tensions
through his critiques of Duke Ellington, a black musician who seemingly
accepted the racism in front of him in order to find success with his jazz
music. The dialogue between the musician and the audience became a dialogue
between whites and blacks, which created and perpetuated the racial tensions
occurring during the Swing Era, making race a predominant topic of the 1930s.
Comment on Steenalisa Tilcock's Blog:
I really liked how you incorporated the Great Depression as one of the reasons for the racial tension that became apparent in the 1930s, which propelled black jazz musicians to an even lower socio-economic status. This forced a competition for job opportunities, which the black jazz musicians had not seen before the 1930s. I also appreciate how you included how the growing national market for jazz emerged, creating a tension between white and black jazz musicians to produce music for the growing white audience. Overall, you bring up good arguments that are clear and easy to follow. Great job!
Comment on Steenalisa Tilcock's Blog:
I really liked how you incorporated the Great Depression as one of the reasons for the racial tension that became apparent in the 1930s, which propelled black jazz musicians to an even lower socio-economic status. This forced a competition for job opportunities, which the black jazz musicians had not seen before the 1930s. I also appreciate how you included how the growing national market for jazz emerged, creating a tension between white and black jazz musicians to produce music for the growing white audience. Overall, you bring up good arguments that are clear and easy to follow. Great job!