Thursday, February 12, 2015

Racism and the Swing Era

Racism and the Swing Era

As jazz music gained popularity, it moved from being a music “for blacks” to a music played by blacks, who catered to a mostly white audience. There was also a spike in the number of white musicians playing jazz music, which played for a predominantly white audience, creating racial tension in the process. This shift of audience created a new dialogue between the jazz musicians and white audience, from which we can see the emergence of the “Swing Era” of the 1930s. The Swing Era represents a clash between races, brought about by the rising number of white musicians and agents who controlled black musicians through their greater access to resources such as nightclub bookings and recording opportunities.
Duke Ellington was one black jazz musician who recognized this racial tension between white and black musicians and audiences, and was able to accept the contradictions of jazz and use them to his advantage. A lot of his success can be attributed to his strategic hiring of Irving Mills, a white agent who raised Duke’s profile, got him radio appearances and national tour dates that allowed Duke to survive as a black jazz musician. In return, however, Irving Mills got co-authorship of Ellington’s composition, which put Duke at a financial disadvantage. Regardless, Ellington was able to find success as a black jazz musician because of his partnership with Irving Mills, who connected him with the growing white audience during the Swing Era.
In contrast to Duke Ellington, many other black jazz musicians suffered from this racial tension that arose during the Swing Era, especially Fletcher Henderson. Fletcher Henderson, unlike Duke Ellington, did not learn to accept the racial tension and instead tried to find success as a jazz musician on his own, without the help of a white agent like Irving Mills. Duke, unlike Fletcher, therefore booked many more performances in major nightclubs like The Cotton Club in Harlem, in which he played for a solely white audience. Duke even began to receive criticism from radical whites, like John Hammond, who called him out for not speaking out about the racism occurring around him. Referring to Duke’s Black, Brown, and Beige composition, Gioia explains that “With encouragement, Ellington might have pushed further in the directions outlined by this massive composition. Instead the mixed reactions of the critics gave him pause”(177). This statement acknowledges the fact that Ellington’s compositions were largely played in order to please his audience, which became predominantly white during the 1930s.

The Swing Era represented a time of conflict between the races, which was exacerbated by the competition between black jazz musicians and the rising number of white jazz musicians in the 1930s. Radicals like John Hammond brought light to these racial tensions through his critiques of Duke Ellington, a black musician who seemingly accepted the racism in front of him in order to find success with his jazz music. The dialogue between the musician and the audience became a dialogue between whites and blacks, which created and perpetuated the racial tensions occurring during the Swing Era, making race a predominant topic of the 1930s.


Comment on Steenalisa Tilcock's Blog:

I really liked how you incorporated the Great Depression as one of the reasons for the racial tension that became apparent in the 1930s, which propelled black jazz musicians to an even lower socio-economic status. This forced a competition for job opportunities, which the black jazz musicians had not seen before the 1930s. I also appreciate how you included how the growing national market for jazz emerged, creating a tension between white and black jazz musicians to produce music for the growing white audience. Overall, you bring up good arguments that are clear and easy to follow. Great job!

Thursday, February 5, 2015

New York's New Jazz

Rebekah Ent
George Blake
Black Studies 14
4 February 2015

New York’s New Jazz

Ken Burns theorized that certain superlative individuals, such as Louis Armstrong, created jazz, and brought it to the places that they traveled. Bakhtin, however, brings up a more sophisticated theory of the production of jazz in saying that jazz is a dialogue between the musician and his or her “socially specific environment”. This dialogue, arguably, is the most important factor in discussing the origins of the most successful jazz music because jazz flourishes wherever this dialogue takes place. While Chicago was an important city for the beginnings of jazz, jazz musicians truly thrived in New York because the diverse population and culture provided a place where true dialogue between jazz musicians and the community could take place, popularizing and creating a new form of jazz music.
New York witnessed a huge migration of over 90,000 blacks in by 1910, and 150,000 blacks by 1920 and has been known as the most heterogeneous Northern city for much of American history. These immigrants’ Southern traditions, such as ring-shout, persisted among the Northerners, as well as combined with the Northerners’ traditions to create new types of music such as the “Carolina Shout”, stride pianists and their piano rolls, and fox-trot dances. This huge amount of diversity led to the perfect place where a dialogue between the performer and the audience could take place.
Harlem in particular represented a place of huge diversity where jazz musicians had to learn to adapt their style according to who was in their audience. In Harlem Rent Parties, jazz musicians started playing ragtime beats on the piano called stride, which eventually formed into the unique New York style of jazz. Three of the most important New York stride musicians were James P. Johnson, The Lion, and Fats Weller, who popularized this new form of jazz. They were new kinds of artists, who were not just individual talents, but people with the ability to recognize what the audience wanted from them, and perform a new style of jazz that appealed to the particular audience. New York represented a place where the dialogue between the jazz musicians and their audiences could take place, which led to the popularization and creation of a new form of jazz.


Comment on Mark Samet’s Blog:

I think you bring up a very thoughtful point when you argue that the economic situation in New York brought a lot of people there, as well as funded the places that jazz music was being played such as nightclubs. You also make a good argument when you say that Thomas “Fats” Waller’s success came from his family’s good economic standing and ability to send him to Juilliard for music training under James P. Johnson. Overall, you include good arguments for why New York is the center of the popularization of jazz music, and you mention that the piano was New York’s trademark jazz instrument, which was important as well.