Rebekah Ent
George Blake
Black Studies 14
4 February 2015
New York’s New Jazz
Ken Burns theorized that certain
superlative individuals, such as Louis Armstrong, created jazz, and brought it
to the places that they traveled. Bakhtin, however, brings up a more
sophisticated theory of the production of jazz in saying that jazz is a dialogue
between the musician and his or her “socially specific environment”. This
dialogue, arguably, is the most important factor in discussing the origins of
the most successful jazz music because jazz flourishes wherever this dialogue
takes place. While Chicago was an important city for the beginnings of jazz, jazz
musicians truly thrived in New York because the diverse population and culture
provided a place where true dialogue between jazz musicians and the community
could take place, popularizing and creating a new form of jazz music.
New York witnessed a huge migration
of over 90,000 blacks in by 1910, and 150,000 blacks by 1920 and has been known
as the most heterogeneous Northern city for much of American history. These
immigrants’ Southern traditions, such as ring-shout, persisted among the
Northerners, as well as combined with the Northerners’ traditions to create new
types of music such as the “Carolina Shout”, stride pianists and their piano
rolls, and fox-trot dances. This huge amount of diversity led to the perfect
place where a dialogue between the performer and the audience could take place.
Harlem in particular represented a
place of huge diversity where jazz musicians had to learn to adapt their style
according to who was in their audience. In Harlem Rent Parties, jazz musicians
started playing ragtime beats on the piano called stride, which eventually
formed into the unique New York style of jazz. Three of the most important New
York stride musicians were James P. Johnson, The Lion, and Fats Weller, who
popularized this new form of jazz. They were new kinds of artists, who were not
just individual talents, but people with the ability to recognize what the
audience wanted from them, and perform a new style of jazz that appealed to the
particular audience. New York represented a place where the dialogue between
the jazz musicians and their audiences could take place, which led to the
popularization and creation of a new form of jazz.
Comment on Mark Samet’s Blog:
I think you bring up a very
thoughtful point when you argue that the economic situation in New York brought
a lot of people there, as well as funded the places that jazz music was being
played such as nightclubs. You also make a good argument when you say that
Thomas “Fats” Waller’s success came from his family’s good economic standing
and ability to send him to Juilliard for music training under James P. Johnson.
Overall, you include good arguments for why New York is the center of the
popularization of jazz music, and you mention that the piano was New York’s
trademark jazz instrument, which was important as well.
Though I wrote that Chicago was more important to the development of jazz, I think you make some great points about New York's influence. I like that you emphasize the diversity New York had and discuss the Harlem rent parties, which were so unique to New York's jazz era. You make a good point in mentioning how the New York jazz musicians recognized the audience's desire for certain styles of jazz and how they catered to their wants. Great job!
ReplyDeleteI agree that New York had a greater influence that Chicago did. Your use of Bakhtin theory was a great addition into why jazz was so successful in New York. In my blog I also mention that musicians wanted to stay relevant, so they catered to audiences (rich whites) desires. Overall you give great detail, good arguments, and valid points to why New York prevails as the more important city.
ReplyDeleteI agree. While many could argue that Chicago was important in making jazz mainstream, New York's abundance of opportunity allowed for its synthesis as an art form. The cultural diversity present in New York in the 1920s provided space for varying dialogues between artist and community, thus creating a condition for jazz to flourish. In my response, I also mentioned Broadway and the African American Reviews as being a significant platform for the commercializing of jazz and black urban life. With broadway, other forms took shape that diversified jazz- tap, dance, comedy-- all these components helped created this cultural and artistic phenomenon that has always had roots to New York City. Great job is organizing your blog post and the introduction makes an awesome point.
ReplyDeleteI liked that you discussed the dialogue between jazz musicians and the community/ “socially specific environment”, because it’s a particularly interesting theme as well as an important one. It would have been cool to see a little more explicit, specific discussion of how that conversation played out with regard to the other points you made (such as why rent parties helped create a new form of NY jazz, and why that new form had the elements it did).
ReplyDelete