The Relation of Jazz to Violence and Community
While some art and music historians
believe that the musician is at the center of the creation of musical
movements, more modern thought attributes the growth of music, such as jazz, to
the relationship between the musician and their audience. Robin Kelley’s
biography of Thelonious Monk and the film, Leimert
Park, portrays this more modern stance as they attribute the emergence of
jazz to the dialogue between the musician and the community for which they
perform. For Thelonious Monk, this community was San Juan Hill, while Leimart
Park represented a place where the community of musicians and audience could
come together. Both places experienced violence in response to racism of the
1900s, and the communities came together through music as an outlet from this
violence.
Thelonious
Monk and his siblings were raised by a single mother, Barbara, and moved to San
Juan Hill in 1922. San Juan Hill was home to ongoing race riots between 1900
and 1917, and “San Juan Hill’s reputation as a violent community was as strong
as ever by the time the Monks settled there”(Kelley, 19). Monk explained that
“We had to fight to make it so we could walk the streets… Then, besides
fighting the ofays, you had to fight each other”(Kelley, 18-19). Aside from the
racism, however, San Juan Hill represented a diverse community rich with
musical talent and culture brought from Cuba, Puerto Rico, the British West
Indies, Germany, Italy, Ireland, and the southern states(Kelley, 18). Monk’s
early interest in music can be attributed to the Caribbean music he was exposed
to in block parties on West 63rd Street in San Juan Hill, which
became a source of “cultural exchange”(Kelley, 23). Then, Monk’s life was
changed forever when a lady gave his family a piano when they moved to an
apartment in the Phipps Houses. Monk started taking piano lessons at age 11
from Simon Wolf, then was influenced by local jazz musician Alberta Simmons.
Another source of Monk’s musical knowledge was his church, where he would watch
others perform and occasionally play the piano himself. Perhaps the most
important factor in forming Monk’s musical genius was the Columbus Hill
Neighborhood Center, an institution for youths that his mother sent him and his
siblings to during the summer. Even though Monk received second place in a
“music contest for a scholarship to the Julliard School of Music”, Monk began
his famous career in the years to follow. Monk began performing in rent
parties, and eventually received gigs at Apollo Theater and their local
Community Center. Thelonious Monk’s genius can be attributed to the community
in which he was raised because of the rich culture and musical opportunities
presented to him in San Juan Hill.
Leimert
Park, like San Juan Hill, is a place rich in culture, diversity, and
unfortunately violence, which helped shape the emergence of jazz music.
Performances in Leimert Park started up as a response to the increase in
violence in the south LA area in order to reclaim the nights as peaceful
gatherings. The people of the Leimert Park area turned to jazz as an outlet
from this violence and a way to come together in spite of the tragedies going
on around them. The World Stage was a business that allowed the community of
Leimert Park to come together by offering a place where people could perform as
well as listen to the music being played. The World Stage was a place where
progressives could come to share their ideas through their music and dialogue
with the audience, which was also characteristic of Thelonious Monk in his
later career. Both San Juan Hill and Leimert Park represent the importance of
community in the emergence of jazz through the dialogue between the musicians
and their audiences.
Comment on Mark Samet's blog:
I think you make a really good comparison between San Juan Hill and Leimert Park in saying that San Juan Hill as a location brought people like Thelonious Monk into the jazz world, whereas in Leimert Park, jazz was the catalyst that brought the people together. I definitely agree with your point that jazz could not have existed without the community, and vice versa, the community could not have existed without jazz. I like your analysis on both Thelonious Monk's relation to jazz through his upbringing, as well as the connection between jazz and the community of Leimert Park. Great work!
Comment on Mark Samet's blog:
I think you make a really good comparison between San Juan Hill and Leimert Park in saying that San Juan Hill as a location brought people like Thelonious Monk into the jazz world, whereas in Leimert Park, jazz was the catalyst that brought the people together. I definitely agree with your point that jazz could not have existed without the community, and vice versa, the community could not have existed without jazz. I like your analysis on both Thelonious Monk's relation to jazz through his upbringing, as well as the connection between jazz and the community of Leimert Park. Great work!
I enjoyed reading your blog on "The Relation of Jazz to Violence and Community"! It gives a great perspective into Jazz as an escape from racism. However, contrary to your opinion, I believe that Jazz was more of a center piece than an outlet. Instead of being a release where people went to get away from their troubles, it was a place where people came together to be apart of the community and enjoy their love for music. Basically I ask the question... if there were not troubles in Leimert park, would Jazz have emerged there?
ReplyDeleteYour viewpoints are very similar to mine. As I was reading your blog a few questions came to mind. Does the violence in these communities facilitate jazz as a refuge or safe place? Also what was the equivalent of the World Stage in Leimert Park in San Juan Hill? Was there one? Was it central park in New York?
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI like how you described the emergence of jazz in Leimert Park, but I feel like you should have explained how it differed from San Juan Hill in the sense that jazz came about to show the positivity and unity coming out of the area. Whereas with San Juan Hill, jazz focused on the individual expressing themselves and providing enjoyment for the community with no sense of togetherness.
DeleteI agree with many of your claims and how the diversity of cultures and violence shaped and influenced jazz. I also like how you described a dialogue between the musician and audience and how that created a sense of community. In addition, this post made me think about the importance of experiences and how everything can affect a person's perspective or in this case jazz music.
ReplyDelete